should custom PBS be allowed in C4 Madden leagueplay?

[SolouCity]

Originally Posted by T Davis

customs are allowed on money game sites because theres no way to really determine if someone used custom or not

exactly.. thats why they cant be banned because there is no way of knowing...

[Was It Teh Chad]

maybe madden will be different... guess only time will tell..

[ZAN]

gonna be a longggggg assssss yearrrrrrr if we have to play the same ****ing offenses every game for 9 months. at least you saw a different look every other game in madden. the demo has no replay value...god help us if the gameplay in retail is anywhere near the same. i may retire lol.

[SolouCity]

Originally Posted by ZAN

gonna be a longggggg assssss yearrrrrrr if we have to play the same ****ing offenses every game for 9 months. at least you saw a different look every other game in madden. the demo has no replay value...god help us if the gameplay in retail is anywhere near the same. i may retire lol.

it wouldnt matter.. custom or no custom people will copy...and use whatever that wont.. not having custom wont stop them

[Was It Teh Chad]

its true in a sense... but they can only copy 1 guy..

having the ability to take anything and everything is kinda lame


regardless im not using a custom book for madden..

[SolouCity]

Originally Posted by XxTehPhenom

its true in a sense... but they can only copy 1 guy..

having the ability to take anything and everything is kinda lame


regardless im not using a custom book for madden..

lame doesnt = shouldnt be allowed... when making rules... personal opinions arent really needed and thats all im hearing in here

[ZAN]

how about one of the traditional aspects of C4, being that it mirrors the tournament community to gear us for that style of play. why in the world would c4 implement every fundamental gameplay rule of major tournaments EXCEPT this one...because it's a pain to have to deal with custom pb accusations if they are banned? I don't think it is. If you see two formations that aren't in any one playbook used together, take a replay of it after the game, and submit it. Commishes/staff open up one of the many spreadsheets out there for our own use, and confirm/deny the complaint....It's not THAT hard.

I would be willing to join a group of people who review custom book complaints if workload is the underlying issue in this situation. It's a no-brainer to me.

[SolouCity]

Originally Posted by ZAN

how about one of the traditional aspects of C4, being that it mirrors the tournament community to gear us for that style of play. why in the world would c4 implement every fundamental gameplay rule of major tournaments EXCEPT this one...because it's a pain to have to deal with custom pb accusations if they are banned? I don't think it is. If you see two formations that aren't in any one playbook used together, take a replay of it after the game, and submit it. Commishes/staff open up one of the many spreadsheets out there for our own use, and confirm/deny the complaint....It's not THAT hard.

I would be willing to join a group of people who review custom book complaints if workload is the underlying issue in this situation. It's a no-brainer to me.

yea in a perfect world that would work..... its not a pain to deal with... its impossible to deal with... unless like you said have some one replay then have it submitted to a commish then find out the pb the "accuser" was said to be using then look thru that playbook.... check the formations of every playbook in the game to see if hes lying about it... but in all honestly.... im not doing that.. and im pretty sure any commish/staff wont be doing it either because its basically pointless.. there is no reasons for custom playbooks to be banned... ... at tournaments you can see what pb they are using so of course its a simple way to stop it from being used offline.. and the only reason it would be banned is because of the time it takes to create one and the use of mem cards etc....


what about jus picking a standard pb but adding every play to that formation....
u wont have any idea at all


what do you do if you think sum1 is using a custom?
do you quit the game? finish then file complaint? pause tlk 2 a commish?


its too much grey area....

[ZAN]

valid points. fine. ill still lab my own ish up...but since they will be allowed...ill be adding everyones offenses to my book. not gonna put myself at a disadvantage in league play because id rather be gearing up for a tournament...see how asinine that sounds?! welp, thats the world we play in now.

[Was It Teh Chad]

still gonna play in both leagues regardless, im just hoping that the selection screen stays like the other maddens, so we can monitor this.

but either way... hide your plays, hide your formations, cuz im jocking everything out here

edit: didnt mean it to sound it like it came out..